Annual report: Supreme Court ruling gave hope but Persian Christians still have no #place2worship 25 January 2022 News Two rulings at the end of 2021 offered hope that one day Iranian Christians may no longer be charged with “acting against national security” for simply meeting together to worship in their homes. First, on 3 November, the Supreme Court ruled that nine Christians serving five-year sentences for their involvement in house-churches, and the propagation of what was referred to as the “Evangelical Zionist sect”, should not have been convicted of “acting against national security”. Then, on 30 November, the public prosecutor of the Civil and Revolutionary Court in the western city of Dezful decided there was no grounds to charge eight other Christians, saying they “merely converted to a different religion”, which is “not criminalised in the laws of Iran”, and “didn’t carry out any propaganda against other groups”. But aside from these late glimmers of hope, Article18’s latest annual report, released today in collaboration with CSW, Open Doors International and Middle East Concern, shows Iranian Christians continued to suffer widespread violations of their rights in 2021. Of the publicly reported cases alone, 30 Christians endured imprisonment or exile in 2021 on charges related to their faith or religious activities, and 21 were still serving these sentences at the end of the year – 18 in prison, one in exile, and two more serving the remainder of their sentences at home with an electronic tag. Many others faced ongoing legal battles, while Christians continued to flee the country to seek asylum elsewhere, despite worsening conditions for refugees in neighbouring countries such as Turkey. Meanwhile, the first Christians were charged, sentenced and imprisoned under the controversial new amendments to Article 500 of the penal code, for “engaging in propaganda that educates in a deviant way contrary to the holy religion of Islam”. Churches remained closed to Persian-speaking Christians, while they continued to be arrested and imprisoned for attending house-churches, leading three prisoners to bravely ask: “Where can we worship once we are released?”, a question that inspired the ongoing campaign for Persian-speaking Christians to be given a #place2worship. It was in the wake of this campaign that two of the three Christians were among the nine released on bail while their sentences are reviewed. But fears the move represented an exception rather than the rule seemed to be confirmed just two weeks later, when one of the nine Christians was sent back to prison to serve another previously quashed sentence related to his faith. There was also great inconsistency regarding which prisoners were permitted release with an electronic tag – a growing trend in 2021 – and which were rejected the opportunity; or which prisoners were offered parole, and which were cruelly denied it. As the report bemoans, “The differing decisions highlight the inconsistencies that plague the judicial system in Iran, and suggest that favourable rulings reflect the views of individual judges rather than systemic improvements at the heart of the judiciary.” You can read the full report here.
Annual report: Rights violations against Christians in 2021 25 January 2022 Reports Two rulings at the end of 2021 offered hope that one day Iranian Christians may no longer be charged with “acting against national security” for simply meeting together to worship in their homes. First, on 3 November, the Supreme Court ruled that nine Christians serving five-year sentences for their involvement in house-churches, and the propagation of what was referred to as the “Evangelical Zionist sect”, should not have been convicted of “acting against national security”. Then, on 30 November, the public prosecutor of the Civil and Revolutionary Court in the western city of Dezful decided there was no grounds to charge eight other Christians, saying they “merely converted to a different religion”, which is “not criminalised in the laws of Iran”, and “didn’t carry out any propaganda against other groups”. But aside from these late glimmers of hope, Article18’s latest annual report, released today in collaboration with CSW, Open Doors International and Middle East Concern, shows Iranian Christians continued to suffer widespread violations of their rights in 2021. Of the publicly reported cases alone, 30 Christians endured imprisonment or exile in 2021 on charges related to their faith or religious activities, and 21 were still serving these sentences at the end of the year – 18 in prison, one in exile, and two more serving the remainder of their sentences at home with an electronic tag. Many others faced ongoing legal battles, while Christians continued to flee the country to seek asylum elsewhere, despite worsening conditions for refugees in neighbouring countries such as Turkey. Meanwhile, the first Christians were charged, sentenced and imprisoned under the controversial new amendments to Article 500 of the penal code, for “engaging in propaganda that educates in a deviant way contrary to the holy religion of Islam”. Churches remained closed to Persian-speaking Christians, while they continued to be arrested and imprisoned for attending house-churches, leading three prisoners to bravely ask: “Where can we worship once we are released?”, a question that inspired the ongoing campaign for Persian-speaking Christians to be given a #place2worship. It was in the wake of this campaign that two of the three Christians were among the nine released on bail while their sentences are reviewed. But fears the move represented an exception rather than the rule seemed to be confirmed just two weeks later, when one of the nine Christians was sent back to prison to serve another previously quashed sentence related to his faith. There was also great inconsistency regarding which prisoners were permitted release with an electronic tag – a growing trend in 2021 – and which were rejected the opportunity; or which prisoners were offered parole, and which were cruelly denied it. As the report bemoans, “The differing decisions highlight the inconsistencies that plague the judicial system in Iran, and suggest that favourable rulings reflect the views of individual judges rather than systemic improvements at the heart of the judiciary.” You can read the full report here.
Isfahan brothers still missing after Christmas arrest 24 January 2022 News Mahmoud Mardani-Kharaji (left) and his brother Mansour. Two brothers remain missing more than a month after their arrest at a Christmas gathering near Isfahan. Mahmoud Mardani-Kharaji, 53, and his brother Mansour, 46, were with around eight other Christians at a house-church meeting in Fooladshahr on 22 December when the celebration was raided by plainclothes officials, who showed no warrant and did not state which agency they came from. Iranian Christian website Mohabat News, which reported the news earlier today, explained to Article18 that Mansour and Mahmoud’s family members, not knowing which agency was responsible for their arrest, have only been threatened and mocked by the local officials they have spoken to, as they have anxiously sought information about their loved ones. It is not uncommon for Christians in Iran to be held incommunicado for a few days before being able to contact their families, but it is unusual for them to be held for so long without any word. The only recent examples of incommunicado detention of Iranian Christians extending as long as a month were Mary Mohammadi in January–February 2020 and Ayoob Poor-Rezazadeh in September–October 2021. Both were eventually released, but this will not ease the fears of Mansour and Mahmoud’s families at this time. Last week, Iran was once again ranked among the top-10 worst persecutors of Christians on the annual World Watch List by Open Doors International. Tomorrow, Article18 will publish its latest annual report, in collaboration with Open Doors, CSW and Middle East Concern, highlighting the myriad ways in which the rights of Christians in Iran continue to be violated, in spite of regime figures repeated claims to the contrary.
Christian converts conclude prison sentences, but one now faces exile 20 January 2022 News Habib Heydari (left) and Sasan Khosravi. Two Christian converts have been released from prison at the conclusion of their one-year prison sentences for belonging to a house-church, but one of them now faces two years’ exile. Sasan Khosravi, who is 36 years old, and Habib Heydari, who turned 40 just last week, were released from Bushehr Central Prison this morning. They had begun their sentences in February last year, but were sent on leave from prison in March, which was extended on numerous occasions until they were finally summoned back to prison in November to serve the remainder of their sentences behind bars. Now, while there is joy at the two Christians’ release, Sasan faces imminent internal exile, during which time he will not be permitted to seek employment within his specialist profession: the hospitality sector. It is not yet known where Sasan, who is a hotel manager, will be sent for his term of exile, but it is expected to be far away from his home in Bushehr. The two other Iranian Christians who have endured internal exile in recent years, Ebrahim Firouzi and Youhan Omidi, were both sent more than 1,000km from their homes. Sasan is expected to journey into the uncertainty of life in exile with his wife Marjan and their two children – a four-year-old son and 18-month-old daughter – as well as Sasan’s mother Khatoon, who is in her sixties and was among the group of eight Christians arrested back in July 2019. Following their arrests, seven of the Christians – all except Sasan’s mother – were charged with “acting against national security”, “gathering and collusion against the state”, and “membership of an illegal organisation” (house-church), and in June 2020 they received sentences ranging from prison and exile to work restrictions and fines. Sasan and brother Sam were each sentenced to one year in prison, followed by two years’ exile. Habib also received a one-year prison sentence, but no exile or work restrictions, while a fourth man, Pooriya Peyma, received a 91-day sentence, which he served last year. Meanwhile, Sam, Sasan and Pooriya’s wives – Maryam, Marjan, and Fatemeh – were fined, while Maryam was banned for life from working for any national institution, including the hospital at which she had worked for 20 years.
Iran remains among world’s worst persecutors of Christians 19 January 2022 News It was on this day 28 years ago that one of Iran’s most senior Protestant church leaders, ethnic Armenian Christian Haik Hovsepian, disappeared, later to be found stabbed to death. Nearly three decades on, and although the killing of senior Christian figures in Iran has abated, the relentless pressure on the Church continues, as highlighted today by Iran’s presence, once again, among the top 10 worst persecutors of Christians on Open Doors International’s World Watch List. Iran ranks at number 9 this year, down from number 8 in 2021, but Open Doors’ researchers are at pains to point out that this apparent minor improvement reflects only the further degradation in the situation of Christians in other countries and not any improvement in the situation for Christians in Iran. “The 1 point drop in score [from 86/100 to 85/100] was in reality a 0.3 point drop,” the researchers note, “so for all intents and purposes the score and situation has remained much the same as in WWL 2021. The outlook for Iranian Christians, in particular converts from Islam to Christianity, is by no means improving. “The election of hardliner Ebrahim Raisi as president and the amendment and tightening of the penal code is all part of a wider development towards Iran becoming a totalitarian state. “State surveillance is on the rise and the authorities are increasingly exerting a firmer grip on daily life and activities. The scores in all spheres of life are at an extreme level.” Iran has consistently been among the top 10 persecutors, and is one of just 11 countries where the persecution of Christians is ranked as “extreme”, alongside Afghanistan, North Korea, Somalia, Libya, Yemen, Eritrea, Nigeria, Pakistan, India, and Saudi Arabia. You can see the full list here.
Christian convert back in prison just two weeks after release 18 January 2022 News Just two weeks after the release on bail of nine Christian converts, pending a review of their case ordered by Iran’s Supreme Court, one of them is already back in prison – thanks to a ruling by a different branch of that same Supreme Court. Abdolreza Ali-Haghnejad, known as Matthias, has been the subject of multiple arrests dating back to 2006, and his latest detention relates to a previous six-year prison sentence which was overturned on appeal back in December 2014. His alleged crime? “Propagating Christianity.” Now, more than seven years after his acquittal, on Saturday 15 January Matthias was summoned suddenly to the “Office for the Execution of Judgments” in his home city of Bandar Anzali, north Iran, and told he was to be transferred immediately back to Anzali Prison – from which he was released on 30 December – after a Supreme Court judge had overruled the seven-year-old appeal court ruling. And perhaps the most astounding element of Matthias’ sudden re-arrest and imprisonment is the similarity of the charge in both the old case, of which he was once acquitted, and the new, which was sent for a review just two months ago. In his ruling on 3 November 2021, a Supreme Court judge stated that “merely preaching Christianity, and promoting the ‘Evangelical Zionist sect’, both of which apparently means propagating Christianity through family gatherings [house-churches], is not a manifestation of gathering and collusion to disrupt the security of the country, whether internally or externally”. Therefore, the judge concluded, a Revolutionary Court should not have sentenced Matthias and eight other Christians to five years each in prison. But now a different judge from a different branch of that same Supreme Court has called into question a seven-year-old acquittal because this very same activity – “propagating Christianity” – has in fact been found to have deserved the punishment originally decreed. There had been hope that November’s Supreme Court ruling may eventually pave the way for Iranian Christians no longer having to fear arrest only for gathering together to worship or sharing (“propagating”) their faith. Today’s news gives a clear signal that such a softening of the regime’s overall approach to Christian converts remains highly unlikely.
Iranian churches get behind #Place2Worship campaign 14 January 2022 News St Luke’s Anglican Church in Isfahan, one of just four Persian-speaking churches still permitted to operate inside Iran, but not allowed to take on new members. Iranian-speaking churches in the diaspora have added their voice to the call for Persian-speaking Christians to be given a place to worship. The #Place2Worship campaign was launched late last year in response to a question from three Christian prisoners of conscience, who asked where they might worship once they were released, having been imprisoned for gathering together in house-churches because converts to Christianity are not permitted to attend the churches of Iran’s recognised Christian minority of ethnic Armenians and Assyrians. This campaign has been supported by numerous former prisoners of conscience, and now has the support of 33 churches from 10 different countries – the UK, USA, Canada, Turkey, Netherlands, Germany, Sweden, Austria, Norway, and Georgia. Their joint statement, and the list of signatories, can be read below: Statement by Iranian churches in support of the #Place2Worship campaignWe, the leaders of Persian-speaking churches outside Iran, in unison with imprisoned Christians, have a simple question for the authorities of the Islamic Republic: “Where can a Persian-speaking Christian worship?” and not risk imprisonment.We also join Article18 in noting that Persian-speaking Christians are not only deprived of a church but are also arrested by security agents when they gather in their homes to pray and read the Bible. So not only have these citizens been deprived of their freedom of thought, religion and community, but they and their families are not even safe at home.The Iranian government has not stopped at closing churches; it has even turned the worship of Christian converts into a security issue, by confiscating their Bibles and sentences these citizens to long prison terms.In the last four decades, Persian-speaking churches have been closed and many imprisoned Christian leaders have been forced to flee, and some have even been killed.Deprivation of a church is the tip of the iceberg of structural discrimination and systematic repression against Persian-speaking Christians.The government does not recognise the Persian-speaking Christian minority, depriving them of their basic human rights and rights as citizens. In the view of the Islamic Republic, the hundreds of thousands of Christian converts have no formal existence and are nothing more than ghosts.So standing together with the #Place2Worship campaign, we call on the Iranian government to stop persecuting Persian-speaking Christians, to recognise the human rights and citizenship rights of this minority, and to allow them to have a church.We note that according to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, to which Iran is a signatory, “Everyone shall have the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion. This right shall include freedom to have or to adopt a religion or belief of his choice, and freedom, either individually or in community with others and in public or private, to manifest his religion or belief in worship, observance, practice and teaching.” We also call on all Iranians to stand by Christian citizens in this campaign and not to leave them alone in their campaign for freedom of belief.Iranian Church, San Jose, California, USANew Life Church, Amsterdam, NetherlandsNaviderahaie, Amsterdam, NetherlandsEternal Life, Cologne, GermanyAnchor of Hope, Tbilisi, GeorgiaCrown Church, Essen, GermanyWord of Love, Eindhoven, NetherlandsAmbassadors of Christ Church, California, USAChurch on the Rock, Toronto, CanadaEmmanuel Iranian Church, Québec, CanadaThe Spirit of God Church, Bremen, GermanyZwolle and Apeldoorn 222 Church, GermanyYalova Iranian Church, TurkeyAssemblies of God Church, Denizli, TurkeyAlmere 222 Church, Almere, NetherlandsThe International Church of the Cross, Oslo, NorwayRichmond Hill Iranian Church, CanadaIranian Christian Fellowship (Chiswick), London, UKNorth London Iranian Church, London, UKCroydon Iranian Church, London, UKEast London Iranian Church, UKArmenian Christian Fellowship, London, UKSt Aphrahat Iranian Church, Manchester, UKLiverpool Iranian Church, UKBrighton Iranian Church, UKGlasgow Iranian Church, UKIranian Christian Church, Stuttgart, Germany New Life Church, Oslo, NorwayIranian Church of Gothenburg, SwedenHamgaam Iranian Church of Vienna, AustriaLinz Iranian Church, AustriaHamgaam Iranian Church of Linz, AustriaDisciples Church, Toronto, Canada
Christian prisoner of conscience mourns death of only child 12 January 2022 News Yasser’s son, Amir Ali, during his younger years. An Iranian Christian prisoner of conscience is mourning the death of his only child. Mehdi (Yasser) Akbari, who was a single parent, was informed on 28 December that his 18-year-old son, Amir Ali, who had underlying health issues, had passed away in the care facility where he had been living since his father’s imprisonment in June 2020. The Christian prisoner of conscience was given five days’ leave from 1 January, but by that time his son’s funeral had already taken place. Yasser’s leave was later extended to 10 days, but he was forced to return to Tehran’s Evin Prison earlier today. Mehdi (Yasser) Akbari. The news comes as Iranians have been reacting angrily on social media to the death of another prisoner of conscience, writer Baktash Abtin, who contracted Covid-19 in Evin. Baktash’s “crime” was to exercise his right to freedom of speech, for which he was convicted of “actions against national security” and sentenced to six years in prison. Yasser’s “crime” was to exercise his right to freedom of religion by converting to Christianity and joining a house-church, for which he was also convicted of “acting against national security” and sentenced to 10 years in prison. Both ended up in Evin, arriving there just months apart. Now Baktash has lost his life, and Yasser his only child. When will Iran stop imprisoning its citizens only for exercising their rights?
Convert begins four-year prison sentence for ‘spreading Christianity’ 11 January 2022 News Hadi (Moslem) Rahimi has begun serving his four-year prison sentence for “acting against national security” by attending a house-church and “spreading ‘Zionist’ Christianity”. The 32-year-old delivery driver, who has a nine-month-old daughter, handed himself in to Tehran’s Evin Prison on Sunday morning (9 January) so that the property deed submitted by a friend to secure his bail may be released. Moslem was one of four converts to receive sentences in August 2020 of between two and five years in prison. Moslem was given a four-year sentence, while Ramin Hassanpour was given five years and there were two-year sentences for Ramin’s wife Saeede, and another woman, Sakine (Mehri) Behjati. Their appeals were rejected in September 2020. The others remain free on bail, for now. Background The four, all members of the non-Trinitarian “Church of Iran”, were first arrested in February 2020. In May 2020, they spent a week in Lakan Prison in Rasht, having been unable to afford the 500 million toman bail ($30,000) set for them after the charges against them were read out at Branch 10 of the Revolutionary Court in Rasht. They were eventually released on reduced bail of 200 million tomans ($11,500). Ramin and Kathrin have two sons – one of whom was 16 when they were taken to prison and forced to look after himself for the week – and the other was just seven and therefore went to stay with his grandfather.
Lawyer of imprisoned Christian asks what danger his client’s release would pose 7 January 2022 News The lawyer of a Christian convert who has spent nearly four years in prison for “acting against national security” by being part of a house-church has asked what danger the release of his 60-year-old client could pose. Nasser Navard Gol-Tapeh is one of the longest serving Christian prisoners of conscience, having begun his 10-year sentence in Tehran’s Evin Prison on 20 January 2018. Since then, he has petitioned on numerous occasions for a retrial or conditional release, but on every occasion has been rejected, despite emotional pleas from his elderly mother to see her son again. His lawyer, Iman Soleimani, submitted yet another petition for a retrial earlier this week, and told Article18 that none of the charges for which his client was sentenced to 10 years in prison had been substantiated. Mr Soleimani added that he had based his new petition on the recent ruling of the Supreme Court, which found that nine Christian converts sentenced to five years in prison should not have been convicted of “actions against national security”. Mr Soleimani also referenced the recent decision of a prosecutor in Dezful not to charge eight converts with “propaganda”, ruling that “they have merely converted to a different religion and have not carried out any propaganda against another group”. The lawyer also expressed concern about the health of his client. In a message from prison at Christmas, Nasser said he hoped “this year’s Christmas gift from God to all the persecuted Christians will be freedom and dignity”. He added: “I cannot say that everything is fine, because the situation is getting worse every day. Our days here are repetitive. “But in spite of all this, God has given me peace in my heart … and I am still joyful in the Lord, even if there aren’t many obvious reasons to rejoice, or even if the situation gets much worse than this.”